Commercial Real Estate News / Investing / CMBS Starting To Tip: Selloff Begins In Earnest

CMBS Starting To Tip: Selloff Begins In Earnest

Published: 06-05-23 Category: Investing

MyEListings' markets and economics editor and creates content about global macro events and their impact on US commercial real estate.

The Downward Spiral of Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities (CMBS)

In recent times, the financial landscape has been rocked by a noticeable downturn in the price of commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS). Principals, or the individuals and entities that own these securities, are increasingly inclined to liquidate their assets, often at a discount to the market. This indicates a shift in confidence and appetite for risk, with substantial implications for both CMBS issuers and investors.

Recent Spike in CMBS Delinquency Rates

One key indicator that illuminates this troubling trend is the noticeable spike in CMBS delinquency rates. Delinquency rates, which measure the percentage of loans past due, serve as a barometer of the health of the CMBS market. Recently, these rates have seen their largest increase since mid-2020, a time synonymous with economic volatility and uncertainty.

The Driving Forces Behind the Sell-Off

A confluence of factors is responsible for the current sell-off of CMBS. The ongoing fallout from global economic crises, persistent operational disruptions, and shifts in commercial real estate demand are all driving this trend.

The continuing repercussions of economic instability have led to a climate of uncertainty, causing a more risk-averse approach among investors. This is evidenced by the increasing number of principals looking to offload their CMBS, even if it means taking a hit compared to the market value.

Additionally, the operational disruptions faced by businesses, from supply chain issues to workforce challenges, have further eroded the financial viability of many commercial properties. Consequently, the perceived risk of CMBS has increased, leading to declining prices as principals look to minimize their potential losses.

Lastly, shifts in commercial real estate demand, especially in sectors like retail and office space, have put additional downward pressure on the value of these securities. With fewer tenants and lower rental income, the underlying mortgages that these securities are based on become riskier, thus reducing the attractiveness of CMBS to investors. Moreover, remote work and e-commerce, the principal drivers behind the declining value of office and retail properties, are not likely to recede, but to increase further and become more permanent. This suggests that the present decline in the value of these property types is at least partly permanent, rather than cyclical.

Implications for Investors and Issuers

The current downward trajectory of CMBS prices carries significant implications for both investors and issuers. For investors, it presents both challenges and opportunities. On one hand, the declining prices and higher delinquency rates raise concerns about the risk and return on CMBS. On the other hand, this may create buying opportunities for those willing to take on the associated risk.

For issuers, the declining prices may pose difficulties in generating investor interest and could potentially limit their ability to securitize new commercial mortgages. This could further exacerbate the ongoing struggles in the commercial real estate market.

The Path Ahead

The downward trend in CMBS prices is a testament to the changing dynamics of the commercial real estate and financial markets. The road ahead remains uncertain, with the potential for further price declines and delinquency rate increases if the current market conditions persist.

As such, it is more crucial than ever for both investors and issuers to closely monitor these trends, adjust their strategies accordingly, and make informed decisions based on a thorough understanding of the risks and opportunities presented by the CMBS market.

In conclusion, the current decline in CMBS prices reflects broader economic trends and sector-specific challenges. Navigating this landscape will require astute market analysis, strategic decision-making, and a keen understanding of the evolving commercial real estate landscape.