If you are torn between two potential cities, you’re certainly not alone. Philadelphia and Harrisburg are two incredible options for those looking to call Pennsylvania their future home. Of course, one will likely be a better fit for you.
The key to determining which would be a better location for your business is comparing and contrasting the commercial real estate in Philadelphia vs. the commercial real estate in Harrisburg alongside other components like population demographics, market activity, and more.
Let’s take a look at how you can determine which city would be best for your business.
To kick off this evaluation, it’s important to point out that these cities’ largest differentiator is likely their population.
While Philadelphia is the 6th largest city in America with 1.582 million residents according to Census Data, Harrisburg ranks at 802 with only 49,247 residents.
This means that Philadelphia is over 32 times the size of Harrisburg.
Of course, this doesn’t mean that Harrisburg can’t offer businesses what they need to succeed. In fact, its much lower population might actually work in your favor, as we’ll explore now.
Now that we know the population size of these two cities, it’s important to understand who makes up that population: Businesses need to know if their target market is actually living in the area.
Here’s a quick overview of some key demographics for each:
Median Age: The U.S. Census Bureau compared these two relatively young cities with a median age of 31.5 years in Harrisburg and a slightly higher 34.6 years old in Philadelphia.
Level of Education: There’s a slight difference in education between these two cities: 85.7% of Philadelphia residents have completed high school, while only 81.5% of Harrisburg residents can say the same.
Meanwhile, Philadelphia is sitting at 31.2% of the population with a Bachelor’s degree, and Harrisburg is nearly 10% lower at 22.6%.
Poverty Rate: According to a 2020 Census.gov comparison, 23.1% of Philadelphia residents and 26.5% of Harrisburg residents reported living in poverty. However, this number likely isn’t representative of the current conditions.
Occupation: The largest employers in Philadelphia include the University of Pennsylvania and Penn Medicine, Thomas Jefferson University and Jefferson Health, the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, and Comcast.
Meanwhile, Zippia reports that Harrisburg residents are largely employed by the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation and Valenti Mid-Atlantic Management LLC.
According to DataUSA, the average income in Harrisburg is $41,831 per year while families in Philadelphia earn an average of $49,127 per year.
Philadelphia’s commercial real estate market is vibrant and growing while Harrisburg has a limited selection of office and retail space, but there is more industrial space available.
Office space in Harrisburg was going for around $18.61 price per square foot in 2020, while in Philadelphia, the average office space was going for $32.12.
You’d expect vacancy rates to be fairly similar between the two cities. However, as of 2020, Harrisburg was sitting at 10.87%, and Philadelphia came in quite a bit lower at 9.03%.
The outlook for the CRE market in Philadelphia is positive, with a projected 4.7% in sales growth in the next year. Philadelphia is no. 74 out of the top 100 metros for expected growth in 2022.
The outlook for the CRE market in Harrisburg is also positive; while specific estimates are currently unavailable, the office and industrial sectors are expected to see the most growth, while the retail sector is expected to remain stable.
When it comes to commercial activity, Philadelphia is the clear winner. The city is home to numerous businesses of all sizes, and there is a healthy mix of office, retail, and industrial space available.
Harrisburg’s commercial scene is growing, but it is not as robust as Philadelphia’s.
The retail scene in Philadelphia is vibrant, with a mix of local boutiques and national chain stores. The city is also home to several large malls, including the King of Prussia Mall, which is the largest mall in the United States.
Harrisburg’s retail scene is not as robust as Philadelphia’s, but there are still a number of local boutiques and national chain stores. The city also has a few large malls, but they are not as large or as numerous as the malls in Philadelphia.
Philadelphia’s industrial sector is strong, with a number of warehouses and storage facilities. The city is also home to a number of manufacturing and logistics companies.
Harrisburg’s industrial sector is also strong, but obviously, due to the difference in city size, there are not as many warehouses and storage facilities. The city is still home to a number of manufacturing and logistics companies, but not nearly as many as Philadelphia.
Philadelphia’s office sector is booming, with a number of new office buildings being constructed. The city is home to a number of large businesses and corporations, as well as a healthy mix of small businesses.
Harrisburg’s office sector is also growing, but it is not as robust as Philadelphia’s. The city has a limited selection of office space, but there is a healthy mix of small businesses.
In 2020, Philadelphia announced a project which would deliver "more than 1,000 new multifamily units." These included locations like The Laurel, Dranoff Properties’ ArtHaus, River Walk, and a large mixed-use residential tower at 1300 Fairmount Avenue, which broke ground in 2019.
Harrisburg is working hard to provide new leasing opportunities and multifamily residences as well. According to their own 2020 housing report, the city averages around 105 new housing units annually.
So, which city should you choose for your business? If you’re looking for a vibrant city with a healthy selection of commercial real estate, Philadelphia is a clear choice.
If you’re looking for a city with more affordable commercial real estate, Harrisburg may be a better option. Whichever city you choose, do your research, stay diligent, and happy investing.
All figures presented in this article are based on MyEListing.com’s commercial real estate listing data in corroboration with other freely available data and information covering the commercial real estate industry.
You can list and browse commercial real estate in Pennsylvania for free right here on MyEListing.com.
Simply sign up for a free account and get unlimited access to accurate local market intelligence, customized property type alerts, comp software, and more.